Imagine stepping back in time, strolling along wooden sidewalks past antique shops and saloons, the scent of leather and history hanging in the air. This is Old Colorado City, a charming historic district nestled at the foot of Pikes Peak. But beyond the captivating Wild West allure, a delightful surprise awaits: a vibrant and diverse Italian food scene. Who knew that you could discover authentic Italian flavors, from rustic pasta dishes to wood-fired pizzas, nestled amidst the frontier charm of Old Colorado City? This article is your guide to exploring the best Italian restaurants in Old Colorado City, from family-run trattorias serving traditional recipes to modern havens crafting innovative Italian cuisine, offering a true taste of Italy in the heart of Colorado. Forget the tumbleweeds; prepare for tantalizing aromas and unforgettable dining experiences.
Briarhurst Manor Estate: An Elegant Italian Escape
Nestled within the historic Briarhurst Manor, a Victorian-era mansion that exudes old-world charm, lies a unique Italian dining experience. While Briarhurst Manor Estate offers a variety of dining options, its dedication to fine dining often incorporates Italian-inspired dishes and flavors that elevate the palate. Imagine stepping into a grand dining room, surrounded by antique furnishings and the soft glow of candlelight, where impeccable service meets culinary artistry.
The menu here often features seasonal creations that showcase the freshest ingredients, with a nod to classic Italian techniques. You might find a delicate risotto infused with truffle oil and parmesan, or handmade pasta tossed with a rich, slow-cooked ragu. The culinary team expertly crafts dishes that are both elegant and satisfying, creating a memorable dining experience.
The ambiance alone makes Briarhurst Manor Estate a worthwhile visit. The historic setting adds a layer of romance and sophistication to the meal, making it perfect for a special occasion or a romantic evening out. Prices are in the higher range, reflecting the upscale atmosphere and quality ingredients. Reservations are highly recommended, especially during peak season. What makes Briarhurst Manor Estate stand out is its ability to transport you to another time and place, offering an Italian-influenced dining experience that is both refined and unforgettable, set within the context of Colorado history.
Jake & Telly’s Greek Taverna: A Mediterranean Fusion
While not strictly Italian, Jake & Telly’s Greek Taverna offers a delightful Mediterranean fusion experience that often incorporates elements that appeal to Italian food lovers. This family-owned restaurant, a local favorite for years, provides a warm and welcoming atmosphere, reminiscent of a traditional taverna. The menu is expansive, featuring a range of Greek and Mediterranean dishes, with several options that share common ground with Italian cuisine.
Think of their baked pasta dishes – layered with meat, cheese, and flavorful sauces – bearing a resemblance to lasagna. Or perhaps the gyro plate, with its tender slices of seasoned meat served alongside pita bread and tzatziki sauce, offers a satisfying alternative to an Italian sandwich. The use of fresh herbs, olive oil, and quality ingredients creates dishes that are both flavorful and comforting.
Jake & Telly’s boasts a lively atmosphere, often filled with the sounds of laughter and conversation. The service is friendly and attentive, making you feel like part of the family. Prices are moderate, making it an accessible option for a casual meal. The restaurant’s popularity speaks for itself, so be prepared for a possible wait, especially during dinner hours. What makes Jake & Telly’s stand out is its ability to provide a delicious and satisfying Mediterranean dining experience with a touch of familiarity for those who enjoy Italian food, all within a vibrant and welcoming environment.
Paravicini’s Italian Bistro: A Cozy and Authentic Experience
Nestled in a historic building on Colorado Avenue, Paravicini’s Italian Bistro is a cornerstone of the Old Colorado City dining scene. This family-owned establishment exudes a warm and inviting atmosphere, like stepping into a cozy Italian trattoria. Exposed brick walls, soft lighting, and the aroma of garlic and herbs create a sense of authenticity and charm.
The menu at Paravicini’s is a celebration of classic Italian cuisine, with dishes prepared using time-honored recipes and fresh, high-quality ingredients. The Osso Buco is a local favorite, featuring tender braised veal shanks slow-cooked to perfection in a rich tomato sauce. Their pasta dishes are equally impressive, from the creamy and decadent Fettuccine Alfredo to the hearty and flavorful Spaghetti Bolognese. The pizzas, cooked in a traditional oven, boast crispy crusts and delicious toppings.
Prices at Paravicini’s are moderate to high, reflecting the quality of the ingredients and the care taken in preparing each dish. The restaurant often hosts live music, adding to the lively and enjoyable atmosphere. Reservations are highly recommended, especially on weekends.
One of the highlights of Paravicini’s is their commitment to using locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. This dedication to supporting local farmers and producers adds a unique touch to their dishes and enhances the overall dining experience. What truly makes Paravicini’s stand out is its ability to transport you to Italy with its authentic cuisine, warm atmosphere, and commitment to quality. It’s a place where you can relax, savor delicious food, and enjoy the company of friends and family.
The Till Kitchen: An Italian-Inspired Menu
While not exclusively an Italian restaurant, The Till Kitchen offers an innovative and exciting menu that often incorporates Italian-inspired dishes and flavors, making it a worthwhile stop for food enthusiasts in Old Colorado City. This contemporary restaurant focuses on using fresh, seasonal ingredients to create unique and flavorful dishes.
Their menu changes frequently, reflecting the availability of the best local produce. You might find a grilled pizza topped with roasted vegetables and goat cheese, or handmade pasta tossed with a pesto made from locally grown basil. Their commitment to quality and creativity shines through in every dish.
The atmosphere at The Till Kitchen is modern and stylish, with a focus on creating a comfortable and welcoming space. The service is friendly and attentive, and the staff is knowledgeable about the menu and wine list. Prices are moderate to high, reflecting the quality of the ingredients and the creativity of the kitchen.
The Till Kitchen also features a carefully curated wine list, with a selection of both domestic and international wines to complement their dishes. Their cocktail menu is equally impressive, with creative and refreshing concoctions that are perfect for enjoying on the patio. What makes The Till Kitchen stand out is its ability to offer a truly unique and innovative dining experience, with Italian-inspired dishes that are both flavorful and visually stunning. It’s a place where you can explore new flavors and enjoy a meal that is both creative and satisfying.
Other Italian Food Options in Old Colorado City
Beyond the restaurants highlighted above, Old Colorado City also offers a few other options for those seeking a quick taste of Italy. Several cafes offer delicious paninis and sandwiches with Italian-inspired fillings. You can also find Italian-style gelato at some of the dessert shops in the area, offering a refreshing treat on a warm day. Keep an eye out for special events, such as wine tastings and pasta nights, that are occasionally held at local businesses.
Italian Ingredients and Goods
While Old Colorado City may not have a dedicated Italian market, several shops offer a selection of Italian ingredients and goods. You can find imported olive oil, balsamic vinegar, and pasta at some of the specialty food stores in the area. The local liquor stores also carry a variety of Italian wines, perfect for pairing with your Italian meal.
A Culinary Journey Awaits
Old Colorado City, with its Wild West charm and stunning natural beauty, is perhaps an unexpected place to find such a diverse and delicious Italian food scene. But as you’ve discovered, this historic district offers a surprisingly authentic and satisfying culinary journey for Italian food lovers. From the elegant dining experience at Briarhurst Manor Estate to the cozy and authentic atmosphere of Paravicini’s Italian Bistro, there is something for everyone to enjoy. Be sure to check out Jake & Telly’s for a Mediterranean twist or The Till Kitchen for an innovative and exciting menu. So, next time you’re strolling through Old Colorado City, take a break from the Wild West and indulge in a taste of Italy. Your taste buds will thank you for it. This Colorado town delivers unexpected delights, proving that great Italian food can be found even in the most surprising of places. From savory pasta dishes to authentic pizza, Old Colorado City offers a delightful escape for any culinary adventurer.
