Huntington Station. For many, it’s simply a stop on the Long Island Rail Road, a place you pass through on your way to Huntington’s bustling downtown or the scenic North Shore beaches. But beneath the surface, and just steps from the train platform, lies a culinary landscape brimming with flavors, stories, and hidden gems. Forget the preconceived notions – Huntington Station is a destination for food lovers, a place where diverse cuisines and passionate chefs are quietly creating something special. This isn’t just a place to grab a quick bite; it’s a food hunting adventure waiting to happen. So, ditch the usual suspects and join us as we explore the best eats that Huntington Station has to offer, from long-standing institutions to the best-kept secrets that only the locals know about. Prepare your appetite!
Longtime Favorites and Cornerstones of the Community
Let’s begin with the establishments that have shaped Huntington Station’s food scene for years, the places where generations have celebrated milestones and shared countless meals. These are the restaurants that define the character of the area and continue to draw crowds with their consistent quality and welcoming atmosphere.
First, there’s La Casa Delicatessen, a local favorite for homemade Latin American food. Established over two decades ago, this beloved deli is the heart of the Huntington Station community and is known for its authentic, heartwarming flavors. La Casa is famed for their pernil asado, a succulent roasted pork shoulder marinated in a secret blend of spices. The meat is tender and juicy, with a crispy, flavorful skin that is a true delight. Pair it with their perfectly cooked arroz con gandules (rice with pigeon peas) and some sweet plantains for a truly satisfying meal. La Casa’s prices are incredibly reasonable, making it a favorite for a quick and affordable lunch or a family dinner. The owner, Maria, always greets customers with a warm smile, making you feel like you’re dining in her home. One longtime customer puts it simply: “La Casa is Huntington Station. It’s comfort food, it’s family, it’s home.”
Next up, we have Maurizio’s Pizzeria, a classic Italian joint that has been serving up delicious pies for over thirty years. From the moment you step inside, the aroma of freshly baked dough and bubbling cheese fills the air. Maurizio’s is renowned for its New York-style pizza, with a thin, crispy crust and a generous topping of high-quality mozzarella. Their signature is the Margherita pizza, a simple yet perfect combination of tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil. They also offer a wide variety of other Italian dishes, including pasta, calzones, and heroes. Prices are moderate, and the portions are generous. The restaurant has a casual, family-friendly atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for a casual dinner. Maurizio himself can often be seen behind the counter, ensuring that every pizza is made to perfection.
Lastly, we cannot forget The Greek Shack, a Huntington Station institution serving authentic Greek cuisine. The Greek Shack provides a glimpse into the vibrant flavors of Greece, all within a cozy and inviting setting. Their gyros are a must-try, with thinly sliced, perfectly seasoned meat wrapped in warm pita bread with creamy tzatziki sauce, tomatoes, and onions. They also offer a variety of other Greek specialties, including souvlaki, moussaka, and spanakopita. The prices are moderate, and the portions are generous. The restaurant has a lively atmosphere, especially on weekends, when live music is often featured.
Hidden Gems and Undiscovered Culinary Treasures
Beyond the well-known favorites, Huntington Station is also home to a collection of hidden gems, restaurants that are often overlooked but offer exceptional quality and unique culinary experiences. These are the places that food hunting enthusiasts dream of discovering.
Our first stop on this hunt is El Rancho de la Tia, tucked away in a small strip mall, this family-run restaurant serves up authentic Salvadoran cuisine that is both flavorful and affordable. The pupusas are the star of the show, thick, handmade corn tortillas filled with your choice of cheese, beans, pork, or a combination of all three. They’re served with curtido, a tangy cabbage slaw, and salsa roja. The portions are generous, and the prices are incredibly reasonable. It is a local favorite for those who crave authentic, homestyle cooking. The owners are incredibly welcoming and always happy to explain the menu and offer recommendations. What makes El Rancho de la Tia a true hidden gem is the passion and dedication that goes into every dish.
Next, we have Station Sushi, a tiny, unassuming sushi restaurant that serves up some of the freshest and most creative sushi in the area. Don’t let the small size fool you; this place is a powerhouse when it comes to flavor and quality. Their specialty is the omakase, a chef’s choice tasting menu that allows you to sample a variety of their best dishes. The fish is incredibly fresh, and the presentation is impeccable. While it’s on the pricier side, the quality of the sushi justifies the cost. Station Sushi is a testament to the fact that great things often come in small packages.
Finally, we need to mention Taste of Persia, a small restaurant that serves up authentic Persian dishes, from kebabs to flavorful rice platters. While not as widely known, Taste of Persia provides a unique dining experience, offering a glimpse into the rich and diverse cuisine of Iran. The prices are reasonable, and the portions are generous, making it a perfect place to explore new flavors without breaking the bank.
A Taste of Italy
Huntington Station provides the community and those who visit with some amazing Italian food options. From pizza to pasta, let’s take a deeper look at what Huntington Station has to offer.
Villa Marin is an Italian restaurant that serves traditional Italian favorites in a cozy and family friendly environment. They offer everything from pasta and fish to pizza and appetizers. For those who are looking for pasta, try their Penna Ala Vodka or their Lobster Ravioli. The prices at Villa Marin range from affordable to moderately expensive.
Another popular Italian Restaurant in Huntington Station is Posa Posa. This small pizzeria serves a wide selection of Italian foods, from pizza and pasta to sandwiches and heroes. The pizza at Posa Posa is affordable, with each slice ranging from two to four dollars a slice. Posa Posa provides some high quality Italian food options for those on a budget.
Mexican and Latin American Delights
If you’re looking for spice and warmth, Huntington Station’s Mexican and Latin American offerings will certainly delight your senses. From savory tacos to flavorful empanadas, these restaurants are cooking up some authentic Latin American dishes.
La Cocina Hispana offers both Mexican and El Salvadorian dishes. They are known for their tasty tacos, pupusas, and enchiladas. The best part is that the food is both tasty and affordable, with the prices ranging from one dollar to fifteen dollars. La Cocina provides those visiting and living in the community with affordable and delicious Mexican cuisine.
Jibaritos Restaurant serves Puerto Rican cuisine. The restaurant is named after the popular Puerto Rican Sandwich, the Jibarito. A Jibarito is a sandwich that has fried plantains as breading with meat, cheese, lettuce, and tomato in the middle. They also serve appetizers, such as Empanadillas and Alcapurrias. Jibaritos is another great Latin American option in Huntington Station.
Quick Bites and Casual Cafes
Sometimes, you just need a quick and easy meal without sacrificing taste or quality. Huntington Station has a selection of spots for a light lunch, a quick snack, or a delicious takeout option.
Bagel Boss Huntington is a local favorite, offering a wide variety of bagels, sandwiches, and salads. Their bagels are freshly baked, with a crispy exterior and a soft, chewy interior. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic bacon, egg, and cheese or a more creative bagel sandwich, Bagel Boss has something for everyone. They also have some delicious muffins and cookies. Bagel Boss provides an affordable breakfast or lunch option for those in the community.
Another great option for a quick bite is Cornetta’s Village Pump Deli. Here you will find a variety of tasty sandwiches, snacks, and refreshments. With options ranging from Breakfast Sandwiches to Chicken Cutlet Sandwiches, Cornetta’s Village Pump Deli is a great option for someone who is on the go.
Drinks and Evening Eats
The fun doesn’t stop when the sun goes down. Several Huntington Station establishments offer a lively atmosphere and delicious food options that are perfect for an evening out.
Besito Mexican is an upscale Mexican restaurant known for its stylish décor and sophisticated menu. While they offer a full dinner menu, their bar area is a popular spot for happy hour and late-night drinks. The menu features a variety of handcrafted cocktails and a selection of appetizers, including guacamole, quesadillas, and tacos. The restaurant has a lively atmosphere, especially on weekends. While the prices are steeper than other spots in Huntington Station, the atmosphere is unmatched.
Nags Head Ale House is another popular option for drinks and food. Here, you will find a wide variety of craft beers, wines, and cocktails, as well as a menu of pub fare, including burgers, wings, and sandwiches. The prices are reasonable, and the atmosphere is casual and friendly. Nags Head provides a variety of drink and food options for those looking for a night out with friends.
Navigating the Huntington Station Food Scene
Exploring the culinary delights of Huntington Station is easier than you might think. While a car is convenient, the LIRR provides direct access to the heart of the area, making it accessible for those coming from afar. Parking can be challenging, especially during peak hours, so plan accordingly. Reservations are recommended for some of the more popular restaurants, especially on weekends. Many of these restaurants can be found on Google, so looking them up and calling them to make a reservation can be your best bet. Also, be sure to keep an eye out for seasonal events and food festivals, which often showcase the best of Huntington Station’s culinary scene.
Final Thoughts
Huntington Station is more than just a train stop; it’s a destination for food lovers, a place where diverse cuisines and passionate chefs are creating something special. From long-standing institutions to hidden gems, the area offers a culinary experience that is both authentic and affordable. So, the next time you find yourself in Huntington Station, don’t just pass through – take a moment to explore its restaurants and discover the delicious secrets that await. We encourage you to embark on your own food hunting adventure and share your favorite spots with the world. You might just be surprised by what you find. Huntington Station is a culinary gem waiting to be discovered, one delicious bite at a time.
