Imagine yourself in Alexandria Bay, New York, a jewel nestled in the breathtaking Thousand Islands region. Sunlight glints off the St. Lawrence River, the air is crisp and clean, and the promise of adventure hangs in the air. But beyond the stunning scenery, there lies another captivating aspect of Alexandria Bay: its vibrant food scene. Forget just a quick bite; prepare yourself for a true culinary journey, exploring diverse flavors and unforgettable dining experiences. This isn’t just about finding a place to eat; it’s about discovering the heart of Alexandria Bay, one delicious bite at a time. What hidden culinary treasures await you in this charming waterfront town?
Waterfront Dining Delights
What’s more quintessential to an Alexandria Bay visit than dining with a view? The shimmering waters of the St. Lawrence, the distant islands, and perhaps even a glimpse of Boldt Castle – these are the backdrops to some of the most memorable meals you’ll ever experience. Alexandria Bay offers a plethora of waterfront restaurants, each with its own unique charm and culinary specialties.
Let’s set sail to The Riverboat Restaurant. Picture this: you’re seated on their spacious deck, the gentle rocking of the boat adding to the ambiance, with an unobstructed view of the iconic Boldt Castle rising majestically from Heart Island. The menu at The Riverboat Restaurant leans heavily on fresh, locally-sourced seafood. Their pan-seared scallops are a particular favorite, succulent and perfectly caramelized. But don’t overlook their surf and turf option, featuring a juicy steak paired with a generous portion of grilled shrimp. With entrees in the $25-$40 range, it’s an investment in a memorable experience.
Then there’s The Edgewood Resort, where fine dining meets breathtaking sunset views. This elegant establishment offers an upscale dining experience, perfect for a special occasion or a romantic evening. The menu is sophisticated, featuring dishes like grilled swordfish with roasted vegetables and a citrus vinaigrette, or perhaps a tender filet mignon with a rich red wine reduction. The Edgewood Resort’s wine list is extensive, allowing you to find the perfect pairing for your meal. Expect to spend upwards of $40 per entree here, but the quality and ambiance are well worth the splurge. You can soak in the panoramic views while enjoying top-notch food.
For a more casual, relaxed vibe, head to The Channelside Restaurant. This family-friendly spot boasts a large outdoor patio, ideal for enjoying the sunshine and the lively atmosphere of Alexandria Bay. The menu offers a variety of options, from burgers and sandwiches to salads and seafood baskets. Their fish tacos are a popular choice, bursting with fresh flavors and a zesty kick. The Channelside Restaurant also offers live music on select evenings, making it a great place to unwind and enjoy the waterfront scene. Entrees here typically fall in the $15-$25 range, offering excellent value for money.
Local Specialties and Regional Flavors
Beyond the incredible views, Alexandria Bay offers a chance to savor unique regional flavors. While world cuisine is readily available, you simply cannot visit without experiencing some of the area’s culinary claims to fame.
Of course, there’s the iconic Thousand Islands Dressing. Its history is as intriguing as its flavor, and Alexandria Bay is the perfect place to experience it in its most authentic form. While the exact origins are debated, the dressing is inextricably linked to the Thousand Islands region. Many local restaurants proudly serve their own variations, often using closely guarded family recipes. Try it on a classic Reuben sandwich, a crisp green salad, or even as a dipping sauce for fried seafood. The Riverboat Restaurant and The Edgewood Resort both offer exceptional versions, showcasing the creamy, tangy, and slightly sweet flavor profile that makes Thousand Islands Dressing so irresistible.
Another highlight is the fresh seafood harvested from the St. Lawrence River. Perch and walleye are particularly popular, often served pan-fried, grilled, or battered and deep-fried. The local fishermen are proud of their catch, and the chefs in Alexandria Bay know how to showcase its delicate flavor. Look for these dishes on the menus of waterfront restaurants and smaller, family-owned establishments alike. It’s a true taste of the region. The Channelside Restaurant is a great option for those craving a perfectly battered and fried fish fry, using fresh catches from the St. Lawrence.
While Alexandria Bay isn’t primarily known for expansive farmlands, some local restaurants are committed to sourcing fresh produce from nearby farms whenever possible. This adds a seasonal element to their menus, with dishes featuring locally grown vegetables and fruits. Keep an eye out for these offerings, as they represent the freshest and most flavorful ingredients the region has to offer.
Casual Eats and Family-Friendly Options
Not every meal needs to be a formal affair. Sometimes, you just want a quick, delicious bite that won’t break the bank, especially if you’re traveling with family. Luckily, Alexandria Bay has plenty of options for casual dining.
Pizza is always a crowd-pleaser, and Alexandria Bay boasts several excellent pizza places. Al Capone’s Pizzeria is a local favorite, known for its crispy crust, generous toppings, and creative specialty pies. Their “Garlic Chicken Ranch” pizza is a must-try. You can grab a slice to go or enjoy a whole pie with the family. Papa Nick’s is another popular choice, with a focus on traditional, New York-style pizza.
No trip to Alexandria Bay is complete without indulging in some ice cream. Caitlin’s Ice Cream Parlor is a charming spot offering a wide variety of flavors, from classic vanilla and chocolate to more adventurous creations. They also offer sundaes, milkshakes, and other frozen treats. It’s the perfect way to cool down on a hot summer day. Sweet Spot is another great option for those with a sweet tooth, serving up delicious ice cream and other delectable desserts.
For a quick and easy lunch, consider a deli or sandwich shop. Leroy’s offers a wide selection of sandwiches, salads, and soups, perfect for grabbing a picnic to enjoy by the river. The Galley also offers delicious sandwiches.
And if you’re looking for a caffeine fix or a sweet treat in the morning, Alexandria Bay has several charming coffee shops and bakeries. Stop by Coffee Kove for a freshly brewed cup of coffee and a delicious pastry.
Hidden Gems and Local Favorites
While the main attractions are well worth visiting, sometimes the best culinary experiences are found off the beaten path, in restaurants favored by the locals. These hidden gems often offer unique flavors and a more authentic Alexandria Bay experience.
The Deck, while technically part of a larger establishment, is a local’s secret. Situated right on the water, this outdoor bar and grill offers stunning views and a relaxed atmosphere. The menu is simple but delicious, featuring burgers, sandwiches, and seafood baskets. Their fish fry is legendary, and their burgers are consistently rated among the best in the area. Ask for the “Deck Special” – a chef’s choice dish that is always a surprise and a delight. The locals swear by it!
For those seeking authentic Italian cuisine, Bella’s is a must-visit. This family-owned restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere and a menu packed with classic Italian dishes made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Their homemade pasta is a standout, and their lasagna is legendary. Be sure to call ahead for reservations, as this place fills up quickly, especially on weekends. They’ve been a local mainstay for decades for good reason.
Another well-kept secret is Bonnie Castle Resort & Marina. While known as a beautiful place to stay, the food is often overlooked. The restaurant offers delicious cuisine.
Beyond Restaurants: Food-Related Activities
The culinary adventure in Alexandria Bay extends beyond just restaurant dining. Take some time to explore other food-related activities that will enhance your experience.
During the summer months, local farmers’ markets offer a chance to sample and purchase fresh produce, homemade goods, and other local specialties. Check the local listings for dates and locations.
While structured food tours may be more prevalent in larger cities, consider creating your own DIY food tour of Alexandria Bay. Visit different restaurants and shops, sampling different specialties and flavors along the way.
Keep an eye out for food festivals and events that take place throughout the year. These events often showcase local chefs and producers and offer a chance to sample a wide variety of dishes and beverages.
Tips for Planning Your Culinary Adventure
To make the most of your culinary journey in Alexandria Bay, keep these tips in mind.
The best time to visit Alexandria Bay for food lovers is during the summer months, when most restaurants are open and the weather is ideal for outdoor dining. However, be aware that this is also peak season, so expect larger crowds and longer wait times.
Reservations are highly recommended, especially for waterfront restaurants and popular establishments. Call ahead or book online to secure your spot.
Alexandria Bay is becoming increasingly accommodating to dietary restrictions. Many restaurants offer vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. Be sure to inquire when making your reservation or ordering.
The best way to get around Alexandria Bay is by walking, especially in the downtown area. However, if you plan to explore restaurants further afield, you may need a car. There are also boat tours and water taxis available.
Alexandria Bay offers a range of dining options to suit every budget. Expect to spend around $15-$25 per entree at casual restaurants and $30-$50 per entree at more upscale establishments. Planning ahead will help you stay within your budget.
Conclusion
Alexandria Bay, New York, is more than just a scenic destination; it’s a culinary haven waiting to be explored. From waterfront dining with breathtaking views to local specialties and hidden gems, there’s something to satisfy every palate. The diverse food scene reflects the town’s charm and hospitality, offering a taste of the Thousand Islands region that you won’t soon forget. So, pack your appetite, embark on a culinary journey, and discover your own favorite flavors in Alexandria Bay. This lakeside paradise is beckoning you to savor every moment, every bite, and every breathtaking view. Your next unforgettable food experience is just around the corner. Go explore!
