Introduction
Cincinnati’s culinary landscape is a vibrant tapestry woven with flavors from around the world, and nowhere is this more evident than in its diverse array of Italian restaurants. From the comforting aroma of simmering ragu to the tantalizing sizzle of wood-fired pizza, the Queen City offers a taste of Italy for every palate. Whether you’re craving a classic, family-style feast or a modern, innovative culinary adventure, Cincinnati’s Italian food scene promises an authentic and unforgettable dining experience.
This guide is your passport to discovering the very best Italian food in Cincinnati. We’ve explored the city, sampled countless dishes, and talked to local foodies to curate a list of restaurants that truly stand out. We’ve considered everything from the authenticity of ingredients and recipes to the atmosphere and service, ensuring that each recommendation is worthy of your time and taste buds. So, prepare your appetite and join us as we delve into the heart of Cincinnati’s Italian culinary scene.
We’ve spread our search across the Cincinnati metropolitan area, from Over-the-Rhine to Hyde Park and beyond, seeking out gems that represent the breadth and depth of Italian cuisine. The restaurants featured here represent a spectrum of styles, price points, and atmospheres, ensuring there’s something for every occasion and budget.
Classic and Traditional Italian Cuisine
For those seeking the comforting embrace of classic Italian dishes, these Cincinnati restaurants offer a taste of tradition passed down through generations. They’re the places where Nonna’s recipes are cherished and the aroma of garlic and oregano fills the air.
Nicola’s
Nicola’s is a Cincinnati institution, a name synonymous with fine Italian dining. This elegant establishment offers a refined experience, showcasing classic Italian dishes with a modern twist. Their menu features handmade pasta, fresh seafood, and prime cuts of meat, all prepared with meticulous attention to detail. Signature dishes include the Osso Buco, a slow-braised veal shank served with creamy risotto, and the handmade ravioli, filled with seasonal ingredients. The ambiance is romantic and upscale, making it perfect for a special occasion. Expect to spend a premium for this high-quality culinary experience. Located downtown, Nicola’s remains a culinary benchmark for those seeking the best Italian food in Cincinnati.
Borgman’s
Borgman’s is a family-owned restaurant that has been serving up authentic Italian food in Cincinnati for over seventy years. This local favorite is known for its hearty portions, reasonable prices, and warm, welcoming atmosphere. Their menu is packed with classic dishes like spaghetti and meatballs, lasagna, and chicken parmesan, all made with time-tested family recipes. The portions are generous, ensuring you’ll leave feeling satisfied. Borgman’s offers a truly authentic and comforting Italian experience. Located in the heart of Cincinnati, this restaurant embodies the spirit of family and tradition.
Pepp & Dolores
Pepp & Dolores is the ideal restaurant if you’re looking for a traditional Italian experience in the heart of Cincinnati. With multiple floors, you can choose what kind of dining experience you’re looking for with the various atmospheres they offer. From pasta, steaks, and antipastos, there’s a little something for everyone to find here. They take pride in creating a restaurant that is a good experience for everyone.
Modern and Innovative Italian Cuisine
If you’re looking for a culinary adventure that pushes the boundaries of Italian cuisine, these Cincinnati restaurants offer a fresh and exciting take on classic flavors. They embrace modern techniques and innovative ingredient combinations to create dishes that are both familiar and surprising.
Sotto
Sotto, located beneath Boca in downtown Cincinnati, is a culinary gem that elevates Italian cuisine to an art form. This dimly lit, subterranean restaurant offers a unique and intimate dining experience. Their menu features handmade pasta, wood-fired pizzas, and inventive entrees that showcase the chef’s creativity. Signature dishes include the Cacio e Pepe, a deceptively simple yet incredibly flavorful pasta dish made with Pecorino Romano cheese and black pepper, and the wood-fired octopus, perfectly charred and tender. Sotto’s innovative approach and commitment to quality make it a must-try for anyone seeking the best Italian food in Cincinnati with a modern twist.
A Tavola Bar + Trattoria
A Tavola Bar + Trattoria, with locations in Over-the-Rhine and Madeira, offers a casual yet sophisticated take on Italian cuisine. Their menu features a variety of small plates, pasta dishes, and pizzas, all designed for sharing. They source local and seasonal ingredients whenever possible, ensuring the freshest and most flavorful dishes. Signature dishes include the roasted cauliflower, drizzled with balsamic glaze, and the handmade gnocchi, served with a creamy pesto sauce. A Tavola’s relaxed atmosphere and innovative menu make it a popular choice for a casual night out with friends. If you’re looking for a great experience and delicious meal, A Tavola will definitely deliver.
Taglio
Taglio is the place to go if you want a unique pizza. With two locations in Cincinnati, one in Columbia-Tusculum and the other in Over-The-Rhine, it is very easy to find. Taglio offers several different pizza styles from New York style to Detroit Style. They also have a variety of appetizers and sandwiches. Their options are never ending.
The Best Pizza in Cincinnati
Let’s face it: pizza is a cornerstone of Italian cuisine. Cincinnati boasts a diverse pizza scene, ranging from classic Neapolitan-style pies to creative and innovative creations. These restaurants are consistently ranked among the best for their quality ingredients, perfectly crafted crusts, and delicious flavor combinations.
Fireside Pizza Walnut Hills
Fireside Pizza Walnut Hills is a neighborhood gem known for its authentic Neapolitan-style pizza cooked in a wood-fired oven. Their pizzas are made with San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and a variety of high-quality toppings. The crust is thin, crispy, and slightly charred, just like it should be. Signature pizzas include the Margherita, a simple yet classic combination of tomato sauce, mozzarella, and basil, and the Prosciutto e Arugula, topped with prosciutto, arugula, and Parmesan cheese. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, making it a perfect spot for a family dinner or a casual night out with friends. Fireside is an experience you definitely don’t want to miss out on.
LaRosa’s Pizzeria
LaRosa’s Pizzeria is a Cincinnati institution, serving up their signature pizzas since 1954. While technically a chain, LaRosa’s has a fiercely loyal following in the Queen City. Their pizzas are known for their sweet tomato sauce, generous toppings, and chewy crust. Signature pizzas include the Buddy Deluxe, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and onions, and the Vegetarian, topped with a variety of fresh vegetables. LaRosa’s is a classic Cincinnati pizza experience that’s perfect for a casual meal or a late-night snack. This is a restaurant that has been in Cincinnati for many years and does not disappoint.
Goodfellas Pizzeria
Goodfellas Pizzeria is a New York style pizza located in Cincinnati with multiple locations. They have pizzas by the slice if you don’t want to indulge in a whole pie. It is the perfect place to stop at if you want to experience some tasty pizzas at any time of the day. With their unique sauce and pizza styles, you’ll have a flavor experience like never before.
The Best Pasta in Cincinnati
For pasta lovers, Cincinnati offers a wealth of options, from classic spaghetti and meatballs to innovative and inventive creations. These restaurants are known for their fresh, handmade pasta, flavorful sauces, and expertly prepared dishes.
Montgomery Inn
While primarily known for its ribs, Montgomery Inn also offers surprisingly good Italian food, particularly their pasta dishes. The pasta is cooked perfectly al dente, and the sauces are rich and flavorful. Signature dishes include the Spaghetti Bolognese, a hearty meat sauce made with ground beef, veal, and pork, and the Fettuccine Alfredo, a creamy and decadent classic. Montgomery Inn’s surprisingly delicious pasta offerings make it a hidden gem for Italian food lovers in Cincinnati. This restaurant is a must try if you want great food.
Pomodori’s
Pomodori’s has amazing pastas that will make you want to continue going back for more. Their fettuccine is a favorite for many with their unique creamy tomato sauce. They also have a variety of pizzas, salads, soups, and sandwiches. Pomodori’s definitely has something for everyone.
Hidden Gems and Local Favorites
These are the restaurants that may not be on everyone’s radar, but are beloved by locals for their authentic food, warm atmosphere, and exceptional service. They’re the places where you can discover a truly unique and memorable dining experience.
Camporosso
Camporosso is a gem known for its dedication to authentic Italian cuisine and warm, inviting atmosphere. This neighborhood trattoria offers a menu of classic dishes made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Their pasta is handmade daily, and their sauces are simmered to perfection. Signature dishes include the Bucatini Cacio e Pepe and the lasagna. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, making it a perfect spot for a romantic dinner or a casual meal with friends. Camporosso is a true hidden gem that’s worth seeking out for a taste of authentic Italian food in Cincinnati. You’re sure to be back for more once you experience this gem.
Conclusion
Cincinnati’s Italian food scene is a testament to the city’s vibrant culinary diversity. From classic, family-style trattorias to modern, innovative restaurants, there’s something to satisfy every craving. We encourage you to explore the restaurants mentioned in this guide and discover your own favorites. Whether you’re seeking a romantic dinner, a casual pizza night, or a taste of authentic Italian flavors, Cincinnati has something to offer. So, grab your appetite, gather your friends, and embark on a culinary journey through the Queen City’s best Italian restaurants. The aroma of garlic and basil awaits! Don’t forget to share your favorite Italian spots in Cincinnati in the comments below! We’re always looking for new recommendations!
