Introduction
St. Augustine, Florida, the oldest continuously inhabited European-established settlement in the United States, is renowned for its historical charm, cobblestone streets, and stunning architecture. While its culinary scene is often associated with seafood and Southern cuisine, a hidden gem awaits those seeking a taste of something different: authentic Mexican food. The appeal of Mexican cuisine is undeniable, with its vibrant flavors, fresh ingredients, and diverse regional specialties captivating palates worldwide. But separating the genuinely authentic from the Tex-Mex imitations can be challenging. Fortunately, St. Augustine offers a surprising array of options for discerning diners who crave the real deal. In this article, we will explore some of the best places to find authentic Mexican food in St. Augustine, from established restaurants to hidden food truck treasures, uncovering the flavors that truly transport you to Mexico. So, prepare your taste buds for a culinary journey south of the border, right here in the Ancient City.
Defining Authentic Mexican Food: What to Look For
Before diving into specific recommendations, it’s important to understand what makes Mexican food “authentic.” Authenticity isn’t just a buzzword; it represents a commitment to traditional ingredients, time-honored cooking techniques, and regional culinary heritage.
At its core, authentic Mexican food relies on staples like corn tortillas made from scratch using nixtamalized corn, a process that enhances flavor and nutritional value. Fresh chilies, from the mild poblano to the fiery habanero, are essential, providing depth and complexity. Herbs like cilantro, epazote, and hoja santa contribute unique aromatic notes. Traditional Mexican cooking also involves methods like slow-braising meats, grilling over open flames, and using specialized equipment like comales (flat griddles) for tortillas and cazuelas (clay pots) for stews.
Furthermore, it’s crucial to recognize the diversity of Mexican cuisine. Each region boasts its own distinct flavors and specialties. Oaxacan cuisine, for instance, is famous for its complex moles (sauces) and tlayudas (large, thin tortillas topped with various ingredients). Yucatecan cuisine features dishes like cochinita pibil (slow-roasted pork marinated in achiote paste) and sopa de lima (lime soup). Authentic restaurants often specialize in a particular regional style, showcasing the unique culinary traditions of that area.
The key difference between authentic Mexican food and Tex-Mex or Americanized versions often lies in the ingredients and techniques used. Tex-Mex, which originated in Texas, often incorporates ingredients like cheddar cheese, ground beef, and wheat flour tortillas, which are not traditionally used in Mexico. Americanized versions may also be sweeter or milder to cater to a broader palate.
For many diners, authenticity is more than just a matter of taste; it’s about experiencing a culture through its food. It’s about connecting with traditions, supporting local communities, and appreciating the artistry of Mexican cuisine.
Savor the Flavors: Authentic Mexican Restaurants in St. Augustine
Now, let’s explore some of the best places to find authentic Mexican food in St. Augustine. These restaurants are dedicated to using fresh, high-quality ingredients and employing traditional cooking methods to create dishes that truly capture the essence of Mexican cuisine.
Coyoacán Mexican Restaurant
Nestled on Anastasia Island, Coyoacán Mexican Restaurant is a local favorite known for its vibrant atmosphere and dedication to traditional Mexican recipes. This family-owned establishment prides itself on using fresh, locally sourced ingredients whenever possible.
Their signature dish, Mole Poblano, is a testament to their commitment to authenticity. Made with a complex blend of chilies, spices, and chocolate, this rich, dark sauce is a true labor of love, slow-cooked to perfection and served over tender chicken. Their Tacos al Pastor are also a must-try, featuring marinated pork cooked on a vertical spit, thinly sliced and served on warm corn tortillas with pineapple, cilantro, and onions. The owner of Coyoacán often says, “We want our customers to feel like they’ve been transported to Mexico with every bite.” Coyoacán has been recognized by several local publications for its exceptional food and friendly service.
Casa Benedetto Ristorante
While the name might suggest Italian cuisine, Casa Benedetto Ristorante, is one of St. Augustine’s best-kept secrets for authentic Mexican dishes. The key is that the owner is a first generation American from Mexican parents and on certain nights the chef makes traditional Mexican dishes passed down in the family.
On a special night you can get Barbacoa de Borrego, slow cooked lamb in a pit with agave leaves. This authentic dish uses a traditional technique and tastes heavenly. Enchiladas de Mole is also on the menu, using the same mole sauce mentioned above. Casa Benedetto also makes their own corn tortillas and are incredibly delicious.
A family member said “We are proud to offer dishes from our family with techniques passed down through generations.” Casa Benedetto consistently receives rave reviews for its delicious food and inviting atmosphere.
El Potro Mexican Restaurant
El Potro Mexican Restaurant, is a popular spot known for its generous portions and diverse menu. While they offer a range of dishes, their focus on traditional recipes sets them apart.
Their Carnitas, slow-cooked pork shoulder that is crispy on the outside and tender on the inside, is a standout. Served with warm tortillas, pico de gallo, and guacamole, it’s a perfect example of authentic Mexican comfort food. Another must-try is their Pozole, a hearty soup made with hominy, meat, and chilies. The manager of El Potro says, “We believe in using fresh, high-quality ingredients to create dishes that are both flavorful and authentic.”
El Potro Mexican Restaurant is a great option for those looking for a satisfying and affordable taste of Mexico.
Beyond Restaurants: Exploring Other Avenues for Authentic Flavors
While restaurants are a great place to start, there are other ways to discover authentic Mexican food in St. Augustine.
Food Trucks
Keep an eye out for food trucks specializing in Mexican cuisine. These mobile kitchens often offer authentic dishes that are hard to find elsewhere. Look for trucks that serve regional specialties or focus on specific items like tacos or tortas (Mexican sandwiches). Check local food truck events and social media for schedules and locations.
Grocery Stores and Markets
Several local markets and grocery stores carry authentic Mexican ingredients. Look for dried chilies, masa harina (corn flour), Mexican cheeses, and other staples. These ingredients allow you to experiment with Mexican cooking at home and recreate your favorite dishes. Ask the store owners for tips and recipes.
Pop-Up Events and Festivals
Throughout the year, St. Augustine hosts various pop-up events and festivals that feature authentic Mexican food. These events are a great opportunity to sample a variety of dishes and experience the vibrant culture of Mexico. Check local event listings for details.
Must-Try Authentic Mexican Dishes in St. Augustine
To truly experience the diversity of Mexican cuisine, be sure to try some of these authentic dishes:
Tacos al Pastor
Marinated pork cooked on a vertical spit, thinly sliced, and served on warm corn tortillas with pineapple, cilantro, and onions. This iconic dish is a staple of Mexican street food. Find it at Coyoacan.
Mole Poblano
A complex sauce made with a blend of chilies, spices, chocolate, and nuts. This rich, dark sauce is often served over chicken or turkey and is a true culinary masterpiece. Find it at Coyoacan and Casa Benedetto Ristorante on certain nights.
Tamales
Steamed corn dough pockets filled with various meats, cheeses, or vegetables. Tamales are a traditional Mexican dish often enjoyed during holidays and celebrations. Ask about special nights at Casa Benedetto.
Sopa de Tortilla
A hearty soup made with tomatoes, chicken broth, chilies, and crispy tortilla strips. This comforting soup is a perfect way to warm up on a cool day.
Barbacoa de Borrego
Slow cooked lamb in a pit with agave leaves. This authentic dish uses a traditional technique and tastes heavenly. Find it at Casa Benedetto Ristorante on certain nights.
Tips for Finding Authentic Mexican Food
Finding authentic Mexican food requires a bit of detective work. Here are some tips to help you on your quest:
- Look for Spanish-Speaking Staff: Restaurants with Spanish-speaking staff are often a good sign that they are committed to authenticity.
- Read Online Reviews: Pay attention to what people say about the authenticity of the food in online reviews.
- Don’t Be Afraid to Ask: Ask the staff about the ingredients and cooking methods used in their dishes.
- Be Adventurous: Step outside your comfort zone and try new dishes that you’ve never heard of before.
- Check the Daily Specials: The daily specials often feature more authentic and regional dishes than the regular menu.
Conclusion: A Culinary Adventure Awaits
St. Augustine may be known for its historical landmarks and coastal charm, but it also boasts a surprisingly vibrant and authentic Mexican food scene. From established restaurants to hidden food truck gems, the Ancient City offers a diverse range of options for those seeking a true taste of Mexico. By understanding what makes Mexican food authentic, exploring the local culinary landscape, and being adventurous with your choices, you can embark on a culinary journey that will tantalize your taste buds and transport you south of the border. So, next time you’re in St. Augustine, skip the tourist traps and savor the real taste of Mexico! You might just discover your new favorite taco spot or mole recipe. This city’s authentic Mexican food scene is ready to surprise and delight you.
